Commonwealth to seek death penalty against HOA shooting suspect - wave3.com-Louisville News, Weather & Sports

Commonwealth to seek death penalty against HOA shooting suspect

Mahmoud Yousef Hindi during his Nov. 2 pre-trial hearing. Mahmoud Yousef Hindi during his Nov. 2 pre-trial hearing.
David Merritt (Source: Family photo) David Merritt (Source: Family photo)
Marvin Fisher (Source: Family photo) Marvin Fisher (Source: Family photo)

LOUISVILLE, KY (WAVE) - The man accused of shooting and killing two members of his neighborhood association at a meeting in September was back before a judge on Friday. 

Mahmoud Yousef Hindi, 55, entered the courtroom smiling as he apparently recognized someone he knew seated behind him. The families of Dave Merritt and Marvin Fisher were there too. They watched as the man accused of killing their loved ones at Springdale Community Church faced a judge for the first pre-trial conference. 

Hindi is charged with the shooting of Merritt, 73, and Fisher, 69, on September 6 during a meeting of the Spring Creek Homeowners Association. Merritt died at the scene. Fisher died three days later. Hindi had been in a dispute with the homeowners association over a fence and a half-driveway he wanted to place on his property. 

Assistant Commonwealth's Attorney Erin White requested more time to prepare, citing more than 100 pages of detective reports, lab results and crime scene reports that still needed to be examined by both the prosecution and defense. White confirmed to Judge Fred Cowan that the Commonwealth will indeed seek the death penalty in the case.  

"We did file the notice for aggravating circumstances today which is our notice we will be moving forward seeking the death penalty in this case," said White. 

The defense declined to comment to WAVE 3 on camera, but indicated in court that it may ask for a different hearing before the next pre-trial conference. 

"There's an outstanding issue of bond, I'm not going into it today, I think it really needs to be addressed in writing," said Mike Lemke, Hindi's attorney, to Judge Cowan. "We may want to notice something like that for quicker than the next pre-trial." 

That next pre-trial conference has now been set for January 14, 2013. At that time Judge Cowan told both sides he hopes they're much further down the road in reviewing all of the discovery in hopes at trial date could be set at that time.

Copyright 2012 WAVE News. All rights reserved.  

  • WAVE 3 NewsNEWSMore>>

  • FORECAST: Cloudy and colder Saturday

    FORECAST: Cloudy and colder Saturday

    Saturday, February 25 2017 4:07 AM EST2017-02-25 09:07:11 GMT

    The rain chances have diminished, but a few sprinkle or flurries will be possible early Saturday with temperatures in the 30s.

    More >>

    The rain chances have diminished, but a few sprinkle or flurries will be possible early Saturday with temperatures in the 30s.

    More >>
  • Sen. McConnell, protestors talk priorities in and outside of Lincoln Day Dinner

    Sen. McConnell, protestors talk priorities in and outside of Lincoln Day Dinner

    Saturday, February 25 2017 12:05 AM EST2017-02-25 05:05:28 GMT

    Electricity was in the air at the 102nd Lincoln Day Dinner on Friday. Republicans were still on a high after a historic election that gave the GOP control of the White House and Congress.

    More >>

    Electricity was in the air at the 102nd Lincoln Day Dinner on Friday. Republicans were still on a high after a historic election that gave the GOP control of the White House and Congress.

    More >>
  • LMPD and the Ferguson effect

    LMPD and the Ferguson effect

    Friday, February 24 2017 11:34 PM EST2017-02-25 04:34:33 GMT

    For the past few years, officer involved shootings have led to unprecedented protests. Backlash and violence at times have been so severe, some police said it made them hesitate or even avoid some actions on the job. It's called the Ferguson effect - a reference to the Missouri town where an officer shot Michael Brown in 2014.

    More >>

    For the past few years, officer involved shootings have led to unprecedented protests. Backlash and violence at times have been so severe, some police said it made them hesitate or even avoid some actions on the job. It's called the Ferguson effect - a reference to the Missouri town where an officer shot Michael Brown in 2014.

    More >>
Powered by Frankly