Jury reaches verdict in Banis murder trial - wave3.com-Louisville News, Weather & Sports

Jury reaches verdict in Banis murder trial

Posted: Updated:
Joseph Banis (Source: LMDC) Joseph Banis (Source: LMDC)
Murder victim Jamie Carroll (Source: LMDC) Murder victim Jamie Carroll (Source: LMDC)
Jeffrey Mundt (Source: LMDC) Jeffrey Mundt (Source: LMDC)

LOUISVILLE, KY (WAVE) – Jurors have found Joseph Banis guilty of the murder of Jamie Carroll. He was also found guilty of robbery, forgery, tampering with physical evidence, criminal possession of a forged instrument and possession of meth.

Carroll's body was found in June 2010 buried in a plastic container in the basement of the Old  Louisville home Banis shared with his then-boyfriend, co-defendant Jeffrey Mundt. Prosecutors say Carroll was shot and stabbed to death in December 2009.

Mundt spent nearly two days on the stand telling jurors it was Banis who killed Carroll. During closing arguments on Thursday, defense attorney Darren Wolff called Mundt's credibility into question while showing jurors a picture of Mundt crying during his initial interview with police.

In a surprise move on Wednesday, Banis' defense rested without calling Banis to the stand. Defense attorney Justin Brown had told jurors during opening statements on February 26 that Banis definitely would testify.

Over the course of a week, jurors heard testimony that was often salacious and sexually explicit. It centered on the nature of Banis and Mundt's relationship and their relationship with Jamie Carroll.

Mundt's trial is scheduled for this summer. Because he agreed to testify against Banis, the death penalty will not be sought in his case.

Copyright 2013 WAVE News. All rights reserved.

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Only On 3

    4-year-old boy banned from local doughnut shop

    4-year-old boy banned from local doughnut shop

    Tuesday, July 22 2014 6:55 PM EDT2014-07-22 22:55:12 GMT
    Kids say the darndest things, but one local inquisitive 4-year-old boy asked a question that got him banned from a Monroe doughnut shop.More >>
    Kids say the darndest things, but one local inquisitive 4-year-old boy asked a question that got him banned from a Monroe doughnut shop.More >>
  • Lawsuit: Princeton BMC doctors amputated man's genitals without prior warning

    Lawsuit: Princeton BMC doctors amputated man's genitals without prior warning

    Wednesday, July 23 2014 10:56 PM EDT2014-07-24 02:56:38 GMT
    A Jefferson County man is suing his doctors and a local hospital, alleging that he went in for a circumcision but when he woke up, doctors had amputated his genitals.More >>
    A Jefferson County man is suing his doctors and a local hospital, alleging that he went in for a circumcision but when he woke up, doctors had amputated his genitals.More >>
  • Are Louisville food trucks making the grade?

    Are Louisville food trucks making the grade?

    Wednesday, July 23 2014 11:06 PM EDT2014-07-24 03:06:24 GMT
    WAVE 3 News Troubleshooter Eric Flack's investigation into food trucks last summer was one of his most talked about stories in years. His undercover video and health department interviews stirred a fiery response. Now, a new report about food truck safety has been released by the Institute for Justice, and it's good news for the industry and food truck operators.More >>
    WAVE 3 News Troubleshooter Eric Flack's investigation into food trucks last summer was one of his most talked about stories in years. His undercover video and health department interviews stirred a fiery response. Now, a new report about food truck safety has been released by the Institute for Justice, and it's good news for the industry and food truck operators.

    More >>