Attorney: KY and IN laws would lead to similar outcome in Zimmer - wave3.com-Louisville News, Weather & Sports

Attorney: KY and IN laws would lead to similar outcome in Zimmerman trial

Bart Adams Bart Adams
George Zimmerman hearing the jury's verdict on July 13, 2013. George Zimmerman hearing the jury's verdict on July 13, 2013.

LOUISVILLE, KY (WAVE) - Both Kentucky and Indiana have self-defense laws and in many ways they're similar to the law in Florida, where the high-profile murder trial of George Zimmerman just wrapped up in the shooting death of Trayvon Martin.

Zimmerman said he shot the teenager in self-defense and was cleared of state criminal charges. Bart Adams, a Kentucky defense attorney, has argued plenty of cases with clients claiming they were acting in self-defense.

"I would much rather have a self-protection case than some of the cases I get because with self-protection at least you have a legitimate argument to make in front of a jury," Adams he said.

Adams was the defense attorney on a 2010 case here in Kentucky that ignited passions in much the same way the Trayvon Martin case did. You might remember it: the shooting death of former Louisville football player Daniel Covington by former baseball player Isaiah Howes.

Early on the morning of September 16, 2010, Howes shot Covington in downtown Louisville after Howes and his brother said Covington came through the front window of their SUV and began throwing punches. The case barely made it into a courtroom because of Kentucky's self-defense laws. It was thrown out before it was presented to a grand jury. Adams says not all cases are that clear cut.

"It's a great gamble as to what the jury may believe as to what the punishment could be," said Adams.

That's because in Kentucky, jurors not only have to decide if self-defense applies, but also if you were wanton or reckless in how you protected yourself. Even so, Adams thinks if the George Zimmerman murder trial happened here, the outcome would have been the same.

"That's the key," said Adams, "the government could not prove beyond a reasonable doubt that he wasn't entitled to it so therefore he's got to be acquitted. What actually happened and what morally happened we don't know and we'll never know."

In Indiana, the law is similar to Kentucky's. You're entitled to protect yourself in your house in both states, and you can assume anyone who breaks in is a threat. Laws in both states also say you don't have a duty to retreat.

Copyright 2013 WAVE News. All rights reserved.

  • WAVE 3 NewsNEWSMore>>

  • Mother of slain child wants to help prevent violence

    Mother of slain child wants to help prevent violence

    Monday, May 29 2017 12:16 AM EDT2017-05-29 04:16:19 GMT
    Dequante Hobbs Jr. (Source: Family Photo)Dequante Hobbs Jr. (Source: Family Photo)

    Micheshia Norment shared a collage of photos that was put together for the seventh birthday of Dequante Hobbs Jr.  Sadly, Hobbs will never get to see age eight.

    More >>

    Micheshia Norment shared a collage of photos that was put together for the seventh birthday of Dequante Hobbs Jr.  Sadly, Hobbs will never get to see age eight.

    More >>
  • Abbey Road On The River is a hit, despite rain

    Abbey Road On The River is a hit, despite rain

    Sunday, May 28 2017 12:29 AM EDT2017-05-28 04:29:27 GMT
    Despite a small thunderstorm blowing through WAVE Country, WAVE 3 News's Abbey Road On The River turned out to be hit on Saturday. (Source: WAVE 3 News)Despite a small thunderstorm blowing through WAVE Country, WAVE 3 News's Abbey Road On The River turned out to be hit on Saturday. (Source: WAVE 3 News)

    Despite a small thunderstorm blowing through WAVE Country, WAVE 3 News's Abbey Road On The River turned out to be hit on Saturday.

    More >>

    Despite a small thunderstorm blowing through WAVE Country, WAVE 3 News's Abbey Road On The River turned out to be hit on Saturday.

    More >>
  • Bath County teacher charged with sexual assault of 15-year-old

    Bath County teacher charged with sexual assault of 15-year-old

    Sunday, May 28 2017 11:04 PM EDT2017-05-29 03:04:31 GMT
    Andrew Couch (Source: Clark County Detention Center)Andrew Couch (Source: Clark County Detention Center)

    A middle school social studies teacher in Bath County was arrested this weekend, and accused of having a sexual relationship with a 15-year-old girl.

    More >>

    A middle school social studies teacher in Bath County was arrested this weekend, and accused of having a sexual relationship with a 15-year-old girl.

    More >>
Powered by Frankly