Which sunscreen is the safest for children? - wave3.com-Louisville News, Weather & Sports

Which sunscreen is the safest for children?

Posted: Updated:
Amanda Vasta Amanda Vasta
Patricia Calvo Patricia Calvo

LOUISVILLE, KY (WAVE) - When you choose a sunscreen for your child, what do you look for? About a third of consumers buy a sunscreen that claims to be for kids and many choose one that's doctor-recommended.

For the Sheehan kids, there's nothing like a day at the pool. But first, their babysitter, Amanda Vasta, makes sure to cover them in sunscreen.

The sunscreen she chooses?

"It says 'kids' on it so I usually just use the kids, and adult for me. I don't know the difference," she said.

But Consumer Reports says you don't need to buy a separate formula for babies and children.

[PREVIOUS STORY: Burned? Sunscreen SPF claims not always accurate]

Patricia Calvo, with Consumer Reports said, "There's no safer ingredient just for kids. Manufacturers use the same active ingredients in kids' sunscreens as they do in adult sunscreens."

For example, comparing Coppertone Ultra Guard and Coppertone Water Babies side-by-side shows the ingredients are the same.

And what about Coppertone's claim that it's the number one pediatrician-recommended brand? Coppertone says it surveys pediatricians to find out which brand they recommend.

Calvo said, "You might think that 'pediatrician-tested' or 'pediatrician-recommended' means that the sunscreen is safer, but those terms aren't regulated. The FDA does not hold kids' sunscreen to a higher safety standard than adult sunscreen."

And while spray-on sunscreens are a popular choice, Consumer Reports said don't spray your kids.

"Kids are likely to squirm around. And that means that they risk breathing in the sunscreen. That can be a lung irritant. And some sprays contain titanium dioxide, and if you breathe in those sunscreens it could be a potential cancer risk," Calvo said.

Another risk? Sprays can be flammable, if they haven't dried and you're near an open flame. Consumer Reports says a lotion is a better choice for children.

One to look for is Equate from Walmart. Consumer Reports' tests show it's a good, affordable choice for the whole family.

Consumer Reports tests show Coppertone Water Babies SPF 50 is very effective against harmful UVA and UVB rays. But it costs more than twice as much per ounce than Walmart's Equate Ultra Protection, SPF 50, which Consumer Reports named a best buy.

Also, be aware, sunscreens that claim to be sting-free or tear-free may leave out ingredients that bother the eyes, but be careful - any sunscreen that gets into the eyes may cause stinging.

Copyright 2014 WAVE 3 News. All rights reserved.